Student Loan Consolidation vs Refinancing: Which One Is Right For You?

student loan consolidation vs refinancing

Student loans can be a significant financial burden for many individuals, and finding the most effective way to manage and repay them is crucial. Two common options for addressing this type of debt that you may compare are student loan consolidation vs refinancing.

While these terms are often used interchangeably, understanding their differences is essential in making an informed decision.

Let's explore student loan consolidation and refinancing, their fundamental differences, and their pros and cons.


What Is Student Loan Consolidation?

With student loan consolidation, multiple federal loans are combined into one. The primary goal of consolidation is to simplify repayment by offering a single method and potentially qualifying for government programs.

Note that you may not get a reduced interest rate when opting for student loan consolidation. Instead, the calculation is for your current interest rate's weighted average. Additionally, direct consolidation loans provide consolidation assistance only for federally backed student loans.

While consolidation can provide convenience and streamline your loan payments, it may not necessarily save you money every month unless you choose to extend your loan repayment term.

By consolidating federal loans, you may retain benefits such as income-driven repayment plans and public service loan forgiveness.


What Is Student Loan Refinancing?

On the other hand, student loan refinancing involves combining one or more existing federal or private loans into a new private student loan. Refinancing allows borrowers to secure a lower repayment plan, depending on their credit records and the new lender's terms.

It is important to note that refinancing is not limited to federal loans and can include loans from federal and private lenders.

One of the primary advantages of refinancing is the potential for significant cost savings. This is because it can give you a lower rate and additional monthly disposable funds.

When refinancing federal loans, you may lose some federal loan advantages. This can include income-based repayment plans and loan forgiveness for public service. Before refinancing, assess these options to determine if you would be giving up any benefits that may be valuable to you.


5 Key Differences Between student loan Consolidation vs Refinancing

While consolidation and refinancing involve combining multiple loans into one, these options have several key differences.

Choosing the best option for your financial situation requires understanding these differences.

Here’s a breakdown of the key distinctions of student loan consolidation vs refinancing:


1. Eligibility

Consolidation is only available for federal student loans, while refinancing can include both federal and private loans.

Eligibility for consolidation and refinancing will vary based on your credit score, income, loan amount, and other factors.


2. Interest Rate

Consolidation does not typically result in a lower interest rate. Your new interest rate will be determined by averaging your current rates. Conversely, a refinance could reduce interest rates according to your creditworthiness.


3. Monthly Payment

Likely, consolidation will save you money if you extend the term of your loan repayments. Often, refinancing results in a lower monthly payment due to a lower interest rate.


4. Federal Loan Benefits

Consolidating federal loans allows you to retain certain benefits, such as income-driven repayment plans and public service loan forgiveness. You may lose these benefits if you refinance federal loans into private student loans.


5. Credit Check

Consolidation does not typically require a credit check. Refinancing, however, often involves a credit check to determine your eligibility and the terms of your new loan.


Pros and Cons of student loan Consolidation and Refinancing

Both student loan consolidation and refinancing offer potential benefits and drawbacks. It’s essential to consider these pros and cons before you decide what to do.

Here’s a closer look at the advantages and disadvantages of each option:


Pros of Student Loan Consolidation

Student loan consolidation can often be a great way to make managing your student loans more manageable. Here's why:


Simplified Repayment

Consolidation combines multiple federal loans into one, resulting in a single monthly payment, making it easier to manage your loans. This way, you can focus on one instead of worrying about multiple monthly loan payments. By doing so, you won't have to worry about missing payments or being charged late fees.

Consolidation also allows you to extend the repayment period to 30 years, making your payments more manageable.


Access to Federal Programs

Consolidating federal loans allows you to retain access to income-driven repayment plans, loan forgiveness programs, and other federal loan benefits. This is especially important for borrowers who expect to benefit from these programs in the future.

Federal programs can help borrowers lower their payments, avoid default, or make loan forgiveness more attainable. You can enroll in a new income-driven repayment plan or sign up for Public Service Loan Forgiveness if you consolidate your loans.


Change Loan Servicer

If you are dissatisfied with your current federal loan servicer, consolidation allows you to switch to a new loan servicer. This can improve customer service, better repayment options, and streamlined payments.

Some loan servicers can even offer student loan forgiveness programs, so it is a good idea to research what servicers are available before you commit to consolidation.


Cons of Student Loan Consolidation

On the other hand, there are a few drawbacks to student loan consolidation:


No Interest Rate Reduction

Consolidation does not typically result in a lower interest rate. Instead, it calculates the new rate as the weighted average of your current rates.

As such, you may end up with a higher or lower rate, but it is unlikely to be significantly different.


Potential to Pay More Overall

Extending your loan repayment term to lower your monthly payment may result in paying more interest over the life of the loan. This is because you have more time to accrue interest, and longer repayment terms mean you'll pay interest over a more extended period.


Limited to Federal Loans

Consolidation is only available for federal student loans, excluding private loans from the consolidation process. The process also requires a credit check, which can present an obstacle for those with poor or damaged credit.


Pros of Student Loan Refinancing

Student loan financing is another way of managing your student debt. You can enjoy these advantages:


Potential for Lower Interest Rate

Refinancing allows you to secure a new, lower interest rate based on your credit history and determined by the new lender. The new interest rate can save you money on your monthly payments or reduce the total amount you pay over the life of the loan.


Cost Savings

A lower interest rate from refinancing can give you some breathing room each month. You may even be able to pay off your loan faster, resulting in substantial savings over time.

The amount of savings you can realize with student loan refinancing depends on your current interest rate and the new loan terms.


Combine Federal and Private Loans

Refinancing allows you to consolidate federal and private loans into a single loan, simplifying your repayment process. As such, you can save time and energy by making only one monthly payment rather than multiple payments.


Cons of Student Loan Refinancing

As with any loan, refinancing your student loans comes with a few disadvantages:


Loss of Federal Loan Benefits

Refinancing federal loans into private loans may cause you to lose access to federal loan benefits. It also means you can no longer take advantage of deferment or forbearance options if you experience financial hardship.


Credit Check Required

Refinancing typically involves a credit check, and your eligibility and new loan terms will be determined based on your credit history. If you have bad credit, this could affect your loan rate and terms.


Potential for Variable Interest Rates

If you choose to refinance with a variable interest rate, your rate may fluctuate, potentially increasing your monthly payment. This could make it difficult to budget and plan your monthly expenses.


How to Decide: Consolidation or Refinancing?

Determining whether consolidation or refinancing is the right option for you requires careful consideration of your financial situation and goals. Some factors to evaluate when making your decision:

  • Loan Types: Consider whether you have federal, private, or a combination of both. Consolidation is only available for federal loans, while refinancing can include both federal and private loans.
  • Interest Rate: Assess your current interest rates and research available rates through refinancing. If you have high-interest federal loans, refinancing may offer significant savings.
  • Federal Loan Benefits: Evaluate your current federal loan benefits and determine their importance to your financial situation. If you rely on income-driven repayment plans or loan forgiveness programs, consolidating federal loans may be the better option.
  • Credit History: Review your credit history and determine if you have a strong credit profile. Refinancing may provide access to lower interest rates if you have a good credit score.
  • Financial Goals: Consider your short-term and long-term financial goals. If your primary objective is simplifying your repayment process, consolidation may be the better choice. Refinancing may be more suitable if you aim to save money on interest and reduce your monthly payment.
  • Additional Factors: Consider any additional factors such as job stability, emergency savings, and potential future income changes that may impact your ability to repay your loans.



Managing student loan debt can be overwhelming, but options like consolidation and refinancing can provide relief and streamline your repayment process. Student loan consolidation allows you to combine multiple federal loans into one. Refinancing enables you to consolidate federal and private loans into a new private loan with potentially lower interest rates.

Each option has pros and cons, and it's crucial to consider factors such as loan types, interest rates, federal loan benefits, credit history, financial goals, and additional factors when deciding.

Remember, student loan consolidation retains federal loan benefits and simplifies repayment. Refinancing can save you money with a lower interest rate. Assess your unique financial situation and goals to determine which option best fits your needs.

Our team is here to help answer any questions and provide solutions that best fit your needs.

Contact us today and start your journey toward debt freedom.

Back to Blog

Related Articles

Is Consolidating Student Loans a Good Idea?

Many students take out student loans to cover some of their education costs. Student loans are...

Is Medical Debt Consolidation A Good Idea? The Pros and Cons

Medical debt is one of the most significant sources of financial stress for Americans. With...

How to Pay Off Student Loans Fast: 10 Tips For Success

At the start, it may seem impossible to get an edge over your student loans. You go beyond the...