Bank vs Credit Union Auto Loan: Making the Right Choice

man buying new care

Having a car is essential for most people, but what should you consider when it comes to financing? In the bank vs credit union auto loan debate, it's crucial to weigh the pros and cons of each before making a decision.

With so many options out there, it can be challenging to make the right choice. Additionally, with average auto loan balances rising 7.7% last year, it has become all the more important to understand the different loan options and what is best suited for your financial needs.

Discover the differences between a bank vs credit union auto loan and the factors to consider when selecting the right loan for you.


How Do Bank Auto Loans Work

Traditional banks are one of the main options for financing your car purchase. These financial institutions offer a range of loan products that cater to the diverse needs of consumers.

Banks typically offer auto loans for new and used cars, with interest rates ranging from 3.99% to 6.99%.

Banks often provide various options for loan repayment terms and duration. They also usually have a wide network of branches that can be accessed for assistance.

Unlike credit unions, banks offer more incentives, such as cash rebates, for taking out an auto loan with them.


What Are the Benefits of Bank Auto Loans?

These are seven of the benefits of working with banks:


1. Stability and Credibility

Banks are typically the most well-known and reliable financial institutions. Although there have been reports of banks struggling financially in recent years, they are generally considered a safe bet when taking out an auto loan.

Banks have been around for centuries and have built up trust among customers.


2. Competitive Interest Rates

They also offer competitive interest rates on auto loans. Banks often have access to more capital, giving them the ability to provide low-interest rates.

This can be a great way to get extra cash for those who need it most when purchasing an automobile.


3. Wide Range of Loan Options

Banks offer a wide range of auto loan options, including fixed-rate and adjustable-rate loans. This provides customers with more choices for their vehicle financing.

Additionally, banks often provide online tools to help you compare different loan types, rates, and payment plans.


4. Established Relationships

For many people, the first choice for an auto loan is typically their current bank. Banks often offer the convenience of established relationships with customers with accounts.

They may give you a good deal if you’ve been a long-time customer and have a good credit history.

Banks may also offer lower rates in exchange for setting up an automatic payment plan from your checking or savings account with them.


5. Convenience

Banks offer convenience when it comes to auto loans. You can get a loan from your local bank, allowing you to make payments in person and access customer service representatives who can answer any questions.


6. Ancillary Services and Resources

Banks often partner with auto dealerships to provide discounts and special financing options for customers who use their bank's loan services.

Additionally, banks can help borrowers secure better interest rates or other financial incentives when purchasing a vehicle from certain dealerships.


7. Trust and Reputation

Banks are well-known and widely trusted institutions, meaning they usually have little issues with reliability.

You can trust them to honor their loans and other commitments, making them a safe choice for those seeking an auto loan.


What Are the Potential Drawbacks to Bank Auto Loans?

However, there are also potential disadvantages to consider:


Stringent Eligibility Criteria

Bank auto loans often come with stringent eligibility criteria. This can make it difficult for those who don’t have a perfect credit score or income to qualify.

Banks also tend to require large down payments, which can be a barrier for many potential borrowers.

This also leads to limited accessibility for unbanked individuals, reaching nearly six million in 2021, especially if they haven't built up their credit scores.


Lengthy Approval Process

Most banks have a tedious and lengthy approval process that can take weeks or even months to complete.

It’s important to note that this is not the case with all banks, but it is something to consider when comparing institutions for your auto loan.


Limited Flexibility

When it comes to bank auto loans, the most significant potential drawback is that they tend to be less flexible than credit union auto loans.

Banks may not be as willing or able to work with customers when finding a loan with terms and rates that best fit their needs.


Additional Fees

Bank auto loans may come with additional fees, such as origination fees, application fees, and prepayment penalties.

Before you sign on the dotted line, ensure you know of any additional charges that could impact your loan agreement.


Less Personalized Service

Banks typically offer a one-size-fits-all approach to auto loans, meaning there is less opportunity for personalization and customization of the loan.

This can make negotiating terms that best meet your needs difficult, as banks may not be willing to accommodate individual requests.


How Do Credit Union Auto Loans Work?

Credit unions are a compelling alternative to traditional banks. These member-owned financial cooperatives are more attractive for members since they prioritize their best interests.

They also operate on a distinct set of principles that are more beneficial for members, like lower interest rates and fewer fees.

Credit unions are non-profit institutions. They typically offer lower interest rates than banks, allowing members to save more on auto loans.

They also generally provide fewer fees and more flexible terms for loans.


What Are the Benefits of Credit Union Auto Loans?

Here are seven benefits of credit unions:


1. Member-Owned and Not-for-Profit Structure

Credit unions are member-owned, not-for-profit organizations. This means that the profits generated by loan interest and other fees go back to members in the form of lower rates on loans, higher returns on savings accounts, and more services with fewer costs.


2. Personalized, Customer-Centric Approach

Because they're smaller organizations, they often provide a more personalized customer experience. They get to know you and your needs so that they can tailor credit union auto loan terms accordingly.

This means you'll get the best deal possible on your loan.


3. Low-Interest Rates and Fees

Credit unions typically offer lower rates and fees than banks. This can help you save significant money on your auto loan.

They also have less stringent criteria for lending, making it easier to qualify for an auto loan with a credit union than with a bank.


4. Flexible Terms and Loan Options

Credit union auto loans offer a variety of terms and loan options that can fit your budget. With competitive rates, credit unions often provide more flexibility regarding the length of a loan, making it easier to find an affordable monthly payment plan.

Credit unions can also work with you in special circumstances like lower credit scores or unusual income sources.


5. Membership Benefits

Members can enjoy additional perks, such as:

  • Special discounts and offers exclusive to credit union members
  • waived fees for loan processing and late payments
  • no prepayment penalties for paying off the loan early

As such, credit union auto loans are often more affordable than traditional bank loans.


6. Community Engagement

Credit unions are more than just financial institutions. They strive to build relationships with their members by actively engaging in the local community.

This commitment helps foster a sense of trust and loyalty among members, which can lead to greater satisfaction when it comes time to apply for an auto loan.


7. Member Assistance and Financial Counseling

Another handy benefit of credit union auto loans is that they often offer helpful member assistance and financial counseling services. Credit unions are typically smaller institutions, meaning their staff often have more time to devote to helping members.

They may be able to provide you with additional guidance on money management and even help you create a budget if needed.


What Are the Potential Drawbacks of Credit union Auto Loans?

These are the potential drawbacks of credit unions:


Membership Eligibility

Unlike banks, credit unions require consumers to become members and contribute to the organization before they can apply for an auto loan.

This requirement significantly reduces the pool of potential borrowers. It can be a roadblock for those who do not meet membership criteria.

Moreover, those who want to join still need some form of credit and banking history, which can be problematic for those who can't even apply for a bank account.


Limited Branch Network

Credit unions are typically limited to a local or regional area, making it more difficult for those who live in remote areas or move frequently.

This is a potential drawback if you need to visit the branch on a regular basis but don't have a local branch nearby.


Potentially Limited Tools

Credit unions may lack the resources of larger banks, which can limit their ability to provide customers with various tools for managing auto loans.

This could include loan calculators and other features that help customers manage their finances better.


Fewer Product Offerings and Options

Credit unions typically have fewer product offerings and options when it comes to auto loans than banks do.

This means you may be unable to find the exact terms or type of loan that best meets your needs.


Slower Decision-Making Processes

Credit unions, being smaller than banks, often have slower decision-making processes. This means it can take longer to be approved for a loan with a credit union than with a bank.

If you're looking for an instant answer or a quick turnaround time on an auto loan, credit unions may not be the best option.


Comparison: Bank vs Credit Union Auto Loan

Now, let’s take a look at how banks and credit unions fare when it comes to the specifics of auto loans:


Lending Practices

When it comes to auto loans, banks, and credit unions have different lending practices. Banks typically require a higher down payment for an auto loan than a credit union does.

Additionally, banks may charge more in fees and interest rates than credit unions.

Banks may also not offer special incentives such as zero-down financing or discounted rates for credit union members. On the other hand, credit unions tend to be more customer-centric and willing to offer lower interest rates and better terms than banks.


Interest Rates

When it comes to choosing an auto loan, one of the most important factors to consider is interest rate.

Banks typically offer higher interest rates than credit unions when it comes to loans, so if you’re looking for a lower rate to pay off your auto loan faster, a credit union might be your best option.

Credit unions also tend to offer better terms for borrowers, such as more flexible repayment options.


Repayment Terms

Banks tend to offer shorter-term loans that require higher monthly payments but result in a lower cost of borrowing over the loan's lifetime.

On the other hand, credit unions typically provide longer-term loans with lower monthly payments but a higher overall price tag at completion.


Eligibility Requirements

Banks often require consumers to have excellent credit scores, steady income, and minimal debt.

Credit unions usually require members to be part of their organization or family before applying for an auto loan.


Application Process

Banks often have longer applications that require more paperwork.

Meanwhile, credit unions usually have shorter applications with fewer documents needed so that you can get a car loan with bad or no credit history.


Customer Service

Bank customer service tends to be more formal and structured, while credit union customer service can feel more personalized.

Banks may have longer wait times or require you to schedule an appointment. In contrast, credit unions often offer shorter wait times, and some even allow you to conduct your business remotely.


Loan Flexibility

Loan flexibility depends mainly on the policies of the lender. Some banks may offer more flexible loan terms, such as allowing you to pay bi-weekly or monthly payments, making extra principal payments without penalty, or even refinancing your loan after a specific time.

Credit unions typically offer lower rates and fewer restrictions on their loans than banks do.


Overall Financial Benefits

When choosing a lender, consider the overall financial benefits offered.

  • Do you receive a lower interest rate or other perks when using one lender over another?
  • Will making payments on time result in additional rewards?

All these factors can help save money in the long run and make it easier to manage your loan.


Navigating the Auto Loan Decision

Making a decision about your auto loan requires careful consideration of all the options. Banks and credit unions offer competitive rates, terms, and fees for auto loans.

Ultimately, it's up to you to decide which institution best fits your needs and budget.

If you’re leaning toward working with a credit union to secure your auto loan, 121 Financial Credit Union can help you find the best rates and terms.

As a trusted credit union in Northeast Florida, 121 Financial Credit Union provides exceptional service and competitive rates. Get in touch with us today!

Back to Blog

Related Articles

Credit Union Student Loans: Pros and Cons | 121 Financial

In this article, we'll discuss and go into detail about the pros and cons of credit union student...

Credit Union vs Banks: What's the difference?

In this blog, we'll discuss how a credit union and bank differ in their organizational structures,...

Credit Union vs. Bank Mortgage: Why Credit Unions May Be Better

In this article, we'll discuss a credit union vs bank mortgage and why a credit union may be best.